Neutrino Analysis Strategy Workshop

→ Europe/Berlin
Johannes Gutenberg University Mainz

Johannes Gutenberg University Mainz

Staudingerweg 9 ​55128 Mainz GERMANY
Lukas Koch (JGU Mainz)
Description

The physics goals of the next generation of neutrino oscillation experiments simply cannot be reached without considerable developments in the areas of systematic uncertainties and statistical data analysis methods. These issues might get solved eventually, even without coordination, but at a considerable risk of delaying the physics output of the next generation of experiments. This workshop will ensure that the international community has a clear picture of the most important open issues and potential solutions. This will considerably speed up the development of these solutions and help to prevent delays in the production of physics results by the new experiments.

Participants
    • 9:30 AM → 9:45 AM
      Welcome: Welcome Session
    • 9:45 AM → 12:45 PM
      All Hands: Map #1
      • 9:45 AM
        Identify goals and risks 1h 15m
        • Set a long-term goal. Get optimistic. Ask: Why are we doing this project? Where do we want to be in six months, a year, or even five years from now? Write the long-term goal on a whiteboard.

        • List the risks. Get pessimistic. Ask: How could we fail? Turn these fears into questions you could answer this week. List them on a whiteboard.

      • 11:00 AM
        Break 15m
      • 11:15 AM
        Map out the road to physics 1h 30m

        List key players on the left. Draw the ending, with your completed goal, on the right. Finally, make a flowchart in between showing how people interact with your solution. Keep it simple: five to fifteen steps.

    • 12:45 PM → 2:15 PM
      Lunch 1h 30m
    • 2:15 PM → 5:15 PM
      All Hands: Map #2
      • 2:15 PM
        Expert interviews 1h 45m
      • 4:00 PM
        Break 15m
      • 4:15 PM
        Organise Notes 30m
        • Organize How Might We notes. Stick all the How Might We notes onto a wall in any order. Move similar ideas next to one another. Label themes as they emerge. Don’t perfect it. Stop after about ten minutes.

        • Vote on How Might We notes. Each person has two votes, can vote on his or her own notes, or even the same note twice. Move winners onto your map.

      • 4:45 PM
        Pick targets for the rest of the workshop 30m

        Circle your most important key player and one target moment on the map. The team can weigh in, but the Decider makes the call.

    • 9:30 AM → 9:45 AM
      All Hands: Start of Day Stand-Up Meeting
    • 9:45 AM → 12:45 PM
      Work Time: Sketch #1
      • 9:45 AM
        Lightning Demos 2h 30m

        Look at great existing solutions. Three minutes per demo. Capture good ideas with a quick drawing on the whiteboard.

      • 12:15 PM
        Divide or swarm 30m

        Decide who will sketch which part of the map. If you’re targeting a big chunk of the map in your sprint, divide it up and assign someone to each section.

    • 12:45 PM → 2:15 PM
      Lunch 1h 30m
    • 2:15 PM → 5:15 PM
      Work Time: Sketch #2
      • 2:15 PM
        The Four-Step Sketch 3h

        Briefly explain the four steps. Everyone sketches. When you’re done, place the sketches in a pile and save them for tomorrow.

        1. Notes. Twenty minutes. Silently walk around the room and gather notes.

        2. Ideas. Twenty minutes. Privately jot down some rough ideas. Circle the most promising ones.

        3. Crazy 8s. Eight minutes. Fold a sheet of paper to create eight frames. Sketch a variation of one of your best ideas in each frame. Spend one minute per sketch.

        4. Solution sketch. Thirty to ninety minutes. Create a three-panel storyboard by sketching in three sticky notes on a sheet of paper. Make it self-explanatory. Keep it anonymous. Ugly is okay. Words matter. Give it a catchy title.

    • 5:15 PM → 5:30 PM
      All Hands: End of Day Stand-Up Meeting
    • 9:30 AM → 9:45 AM
      All Hands: Start of Day Stand-Up Meeting
    • 9:45 AM → 12:45 PM
      Work Time: Decide #1
      • 9:45 AM
        The sticky decision 1h 15m

        Follow these five steps to choose the strongest solutions:

        • Art museum. Tape the solution sketches to the wall in one long row.

        • Heat map. Have each person review the sketches silently and put one to three small dot stickers beside every part he or she likes.

        • Speed critique. Three minutes per sketch. As a group, discuss the highlights of each solution. Capture standout ideas and important objections. At the end, ask the sketcher if the group missed anything.

        • Straw poll. Each person silently chooses a favorite idea. All at once, each person places one large dot sticker to register his or her (nonbinding) vote.

        • Supervote. Give the Decider three large dot stickers and write her initials on the sticker. Explain that you’ll prototype and test the solutions the Decider chooses.

      • 11:00 AM
        Break 15m
      • 11:15 AM
        Divide winners from “maybe-laters” 1h 30m
        • Move the sketches with supervotes together.

        • Rumble or all-in-one. Decide if the winners can fit into one prototype, or if conflicting ideas require two or three competing prototypes in a Rumble.

        • Fake brand names. If you’re doing a Rumble, use a Note-and-Vote to choose fake brand names.

    • 12:45 PM → 2:15 PM
      Lunch 1h 30m
    • 2:15 PM → 5:15 PM
      Work Time: Decide #2
      • 2:15 PM
        Plan the prototype 3h
        • Make a storyboard. Use a storyboard to plan your prototype.

        • Draw a grid. About fifteen squares on a whiteboard.

        • Choose an opening scene. Think of how customers normally encounter your product or service. Keep your opening scene simple: web search, magazine article, store shelf, etc.

        • Fill out the storyboard. Move existing sketches to the storyboard when you can. Draw when you can’t, but don’t write together. Include just enough detail to help the team prototype on Thursday. When in doubt, take risks. The finished story should be five to fifteen steps.

    • 5:15 PM → 5:30 PM
      All Hands: End of Day Stand-Up Meeting
    • 9:30 AM → 9:45 AM
      All Hands: Start of Day Stand-Up Meeting
    • 9:45 AM → 12:45 PM
      Work Time: Prototype #1
      • 9:45 AM
        Prototype! 3h
        • Pick the right tools. Don’t use your everyday tools. They’re optimized for quality. Instead, use tools that are rough, fast, and flexible.

        • Divide and conquer. Assign roles: Maker, Stitcher, Writer, Asset Collector, and Interviewer. You can also break the storyboard into smaller scenes and assign each to different team members.

        • Prototype!

    • 12:45 PM → 2:15 PM
      Lunch 1h 30m
    • 2:15 PM → 5:15 PM
      Work Time: Prototype #2
      • 2:15 PM
        Prototype! 1h
        • Prototype!

        • Stitch it together. With the work split into parts, it’s easy to lose track of the whole. The Stitcher checks for quality and ensures all the pieces make sense together.

      • 3:15 PM
        Trial run 2h

        ‍ - Do a trial run. Run through your prototype. Look for mistakes. Make sure the Interviewer and the Decider see it.

        • Finish up the prototype.‍
    • 5:15 PM → 5:30 PM
      All Hands: End of Day Stand-Up Meeting
    • 10:00 AM → 1:00 PM
      All Hands: Learn
      • 10:00 AM
        Prototype Presentation #1 30m
      • 10:30 AM
        Prototype Presentation #2 30m
      • 11:00 AM
        Prototype Presentation #3 30m
      • 11:30 AM
        Break 15m
      • 11:45 AM
        Prototype Presentation #4 30m
      • 12:15 PM
        Closeout 45m

        Agree on further steps.